November 2026
Bellingham Short-Term Rental Ordinance Held Unconstitutional in Part
16/11/26 14:37 Filed in: STR | Short-term rentals
On September 23, 2026, the Superior Court for Whatcom County ruled in favor of Bellingham homeowners - me and my wife, as it happens - that the Bellingham short-term rental ordinance is unconstitutional in two respects:
(1) The Bellingham ordinances' complete prohibition on renting out detached accessory dwellings for short terms — even though attached accessory dwellings face no such prohibition — violates due process because it has no rational basis; and
(2) The Bellingham ordinances' requirement that an accessory dwelling can only be rented out for short terms if the owner is the primary occupant of that accessory dwelling is unconstitutional for two reasons: (a) the homeowners use the ADU as an extension of their main home; and (b) Washington law preempts the owner-occupancy requirement.
It's hard to fight cities' STR restrictions, and in this case, the City went judge shopping after a different judge ruled for the Suttons at an earlier stage of the case. But even the judge the City preferred couldn't understand why the City chose to impose the foregoing two restrictions.
The City of Bellingham did not appeal the judgment, so it has become final. Parts of the Bellingham STR ordinance are, therefore, unconstitutional. Read Moreā¦
(1) The Bellingham ordinances' complete prohibition on renting out detached accessory dwellings for short terms — even though attached accessory dwellings face no such prohibition — violates due process because it has no rational basis; and
(2) The Bellingham ordinances' requirement that an accessory dwelling can only be rented out for short terms if the owner is the primary occupant of that accessory dwelling is unconstitutional for two reasons: (a) the homeowners use the ADU as an extension of their main home; and (b) Washington law preempts the owner-occupancy requirement.
It's hard to fight cities' STR restrictions, and in this case, the City went judge shopping after a different judge ruled for the Suttons at an earlier stage of the case. But even the judge the City preferred couldn't understand why the City chose to impose the foregoing two restrictions.
The City of Bellingham did not appeal the judgment, so it has become final. Parts of the Bellingham STR ordinance are, therefore, unconstitutional. Read Moreā¦
